The Effect of Frivolous Lawsuits on the Settlement of Litigation
نویسندگان
چکیده
It is commonly alleged that a substantial proportion of lawsuits are frivolous and are filed only for their nuisance value. This paper models settlement bargaining in the presence of frivolous suits as a game of asymmetric information, where the plaintiff knows the true merits of his claim, and the defendant does not, apart from any inferences he can draw from the fact of suit. When there is free entry to the opportunity to make a frivolous claim, the profit from doing so is driven to zero, and the surplus from settlement bargaining is completely dissipated. Several policies dealing with frivolous suits are examined; it turns out that requiring a losing litigant to pay the expenses of the winner (the English rule) does not alleviate the problem, but introducing a refundable deposit does.
منابع مشابه
Optimal use of information in litigation: should regulatory information be withheld to deter frivolous suits?
We examine the value of incorporating regulatory information into the court liability decision and making it publicly available, when the causality of harm is uncertain. Public access to regulatory information, coupled with its use in a liability decision, not only improves the accuracy of court adjudication but also guides victims to more informed decisions about their lawsuits, when victims' ...
متن کاملPeaceful methods of The International Disputes Settlement and their impact on the development of international trade; With Emphasizing on the scope of the energy industry
International trade litigation represents, the extent to which countries participate in international trade, as well as its business activities on various economic issues. Since energy is one of main pillars of international trade, settlement international disputes can play an important role in international trade.This is especially evident in the energy sector, which plays an important role in...
متن کاملTwo Models of Pleading
This paper develops two game-theoretic models of litigation, pleading, and settlement. The first model explores the timing of settlement and the strategic use of pleading by plaintiffs with negative-expectedvalue claims in a full-information environment. The second model explores the timing of settlement and strategic use of pleading in an environment with private information held either by pla...
متن کاملAnalytical, Legal and Ethical Look at Harassment Litigation
Background: The coexistence of human beings requires the observance of moral etiquette, which is called civil ethics in ethics and leads to normative order. In order for civil ethics to have an executive guarantee, a set of laws was formed in the society under the title of civil procedure. One of the lawsuits in this regard is the harassment lawsuit. There are complex issues in the harassment l...
متن کاملContingency Fees, Settlement Delay and Low-Quality Litigation: Empirical Evidence from Two Datasets
Although flat fees are common for divorces, wills and trusts and probate, lawyers in personal injury cases generally are paid by contingency fee or at an hourly rate. Arguments have been made that contingency fees increase low-quality, "frivolous" litigation but counter-arguments suggest that contingency fees actually limit such litigation and instead it is hourly-fees that increase low-quality...
متن کامل